You can't decide between Claude and ChatGPT. You've read strong opinions both ways, comparisons that crown a winner, then others that say the opposite three weeks later. That's normal: these tools change so fast that any ranking is out of date almost as soon as it's published.

So we won't tell you which one is "the best." We'll give you something better: a way to decide for yourself, based on what you actually do. It takes an hour, and it still works when the tools change.

What to know before comparing

A few simple facts, nothing more:

  • ChatGPT is developed by OpenAI.
  • Claude is developed by Anthropic.
  • Both are general-purpose conversational assistants: writing, summarizing, rephrasing, explaining, analyzing a document, helping with code, thinking out loud.
  • Both offer a free version and paid plans, with features and usage limits that vary by plan and change often.

And they're not alone. Gemini (Google), Le Chat by Mistral, Copilot (Microsoft) and Grok play in the same category. Everything below applies to them too: the method matters more than the name on the icon.

Why comparisons don't really help you

A comparison tests tasks that aren't yours. And the quality of an answer depends enormously on how you ask. The only test that counts is yours, with your prompts and your topics.

The method: the home test

Step 1: pick 3 to 5 real tasks

Not trick questions meant to catch the AI out. Things you actually do every week. For example:

  • writing a reply to a tricky email;
  • summarizing a document several pages long;
  • turning messy notes into a clear outline;
  • explaining a concept you don't fully understand;
  • checking or rewording an important text.

If you can, mix an easy task, a task where you already know the right answer (to judge accuracy), and a vague task where the tool should ask questions or admit its limits.

Step 2: write a careful prompt for each task

A sloppy prompt gets a sloppy answer everywhere, and you won't be comparing anything. Use a clear structure: role, context, task, format, constraints, example. If you want the full method, it's laid out in how to write a good ChatGPT prompt.

Example test prompt:

You're a customer service assistant. An unhappy customer writes that their order arrived damaged and they want a refund right away. Write a reply of 6 lines maximum, in a friendly but firm, professional tone. Don't promise anything I haven't mentioned: offer an exchange or a refund once we receive photos.

Step 3: send exactly the same prompt to both

Copy and paste, word for word, same attachment. Open a new conversation on each side, and if possible turn off memory and custom instructions so both start from the same point.

Step 4: score with a grid

For each answer, score 0 to 2 on these five criteria:

  1. Verifiable accuracy: do the facts, figures and names hold up when you check them?
  2. Following instructions: were the length, format, tone and constraints respected?
  3. Tone: does it sound like you, or do you have to rewrite everything?
  4. Length: just what's needed, or padding?
  5. Honesty when it doesn't know: does it flag a doubt, ask for clarification, or confidently make things up?

That last criterion is often overlooked, yet it's the one that saves you from nasty surprises. To understand why an assistant can make things up, read why ChatGPT makes things up.

Step 5: follow up once

A first answer doesn't tell the whole story. Send the same follow-up on both sides: "Shorter," "More direct," "You forgot the constraint about the photos." See which one fixes things cleanly without breaking the rest. That's what you'll deal with day to day.

Concrete criteria to check

Beyond the quality of the answers, the tool has to fit how you work. Go through this list in each assistant's interface and settings, because features change often and depend on the plan:

  • Web search: do you need up-to-date answers with clickable sources?
  • Files: can you upload PDFs, spreadsheets and images, and does the tool read them correctly?
  • Image generation: useful to you, or not at all?
  • Voice: do you want to talk to the assistant while driving or walking?
  • Reasoning mode: is there a slower, more thoughtful mode for complex problems?
  • Integrations: does it connect to your tools (calendar, email, documents, code editor)?
  • Privacy: check in the settings whether your conversations can be used to train the models, and whether you can turn that off. Also check the history and how to delete it.
  • Your language: do the answers read naturally in the language you use, without awkward, translated-sounding phrasing?
  • Availability: are the tool and its features available in your country and on your devices?
  • Your employer's policy: many companies approve one specific tool and forbid others for internal data. Find out before you paste anything work-related into it.

That last point often settles the question. See also how to use ChatGPT at work.

Testing pitfalls

  • Judging on a single question. One answer can be a lucky shot.
  • Being won over by style. Long and confident doesn't mean correct.
  • Comparing different plans. Free version on one side, paid on the other: the test isn't fair.

What if they're about equal?

That happens a lot. Then pick the one your workplace allows, or the one with the feature you're missing.

The real skill carries over

The most important thing fits in one sentence: what makes a good result is mostly how you ask and how you check. A clear brief, explicit constraints, fact-checking: that skill works with Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Le Chat or whatever tool comes out next. If you switch assistants tomorrow, you're not starting from scratch.

Going further

To understand what an assistant generates and what it really knows, when to switch to reasoning mode and how to spot a figure that's too precise to be honest, play the free chapter "Light the Lantern" on Lantern island, in your browser and with no account: start now. And to test your reflexes, launch the friend challenge: 10 timed questions about AI, and it's up to you to beat your friends' scores.

Want to look at Gemini, Copilot or Le Chat too? The guide on which free AI assistant to choose extends the home test to five assistants.

Still unsure which kind of tool your task really needs (a chat assistant, an image generator, a coding tool, an automation)? The free mini-game Which AI for the job? has you sort everyday tasks into the right family of tools.

Frequently asked questions

Claude or ChatGPT, which one is better?

There's no universal answer, and both evolve very quickly. The most reliable approach is to test them yourself on 3 to 5 of your real tasks, with exactly the same prompt, then score the answers with a simple grid.

Are both of them free?

Claude and ChatGPT each offer a free version and paid plans. Features and usage limits depend on the plan and change regularly, so check their websites directly when you're choosing.

Can I use Claude or ChatGPT with my company's data?

Only if your employer allows it. Check your internal policy, and look in the tool's settings to see how your conversations are stored and whether they can be used for training.

If I switch assistants, do I have to relearn everything?

No. Knowing how to write a good brief and check the answers works with every assistant, whether it's Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Le Chat by Mistral or Copilot.